MLB The Show 25 has confirmed over 20 new Legends ahead of its launch. With its yearly releases, MLB The Show attempts to present an up-to-date simulation of major league baseball, with new players constantly added, removed, or transferred. But it also attempts to allow fans to experience the history of baseball firsthand, creating otherwise impossible matchups and adding world-renowned players to their fantasy teams. That’s where the Legends mechanic comes in.
In MLB The Show, Legends are retired players who have made a name for themselves in the world of baseball. Among their number, you’ll find Babe Ruth, Jackie Robinson, Willie Mays, and many, many more. They’re among the most powerful players available in the game, and they can hold their own against even modern teams. Here are all the new and returning Legends in MLB The Show 25, and what to expect from the system in the latest game.
All New Legends Coming To MLB The Show 25
Three New Legends Have Been Confirmed
MLB The Show 25 originally confirmed three new legends in the first gameplay trailer, but it offered a more in-depth look in an updated Legends trailer for the game. Adding to the original reveals of Manny Ramirez, Roger Clemens, and James “Cool Papa” Bell are a whole host of legends new and old, building up to Ted Williams of Red Sox fame at the end of the trailer.
The full list of new legends revealed for MLB The Show 25 is available below. All three of these players will be available in the game at launch, and with no extra purchase or DLC required; they’re free to everyone.
- Manny Ramirez
- Roger Clemens
- James “Cool Papa” Bell
- Jason Kipnis
- Lance Berkman
- Bobby Abreu
- Jason Varitek
- Clay Buchholz
- Gil Hodges
- Darren O’Day
- Hank Greenburg
- Wilbur “Bullet Joe” Rogan
- José Bautista
- Don Baylor
- Bobby Grich
- Jim Kaat
- Ted Simmons
- Reggie Sanders
- Preston Wilson
- Chase Headley
- Norman “Turkey” Stearnes
- Ubaldo Jiménez
- Ted Williams
Ted Williams spent nearly two decades playing for the Boston Red Sox, building a legacy as one of the best hitters in the game’s history. His .406 batting average in 1941 traditionally marked the last time any player officially finished a season with an average over .400, although the recent inclusion of Negro League achievements in official MLB stats recognizes Josh Gibson’s .466 season in 1943. Despite career breaks to serve in both World War II and the Korean War, Williams maintained a standard of exceptional stats across his entire career.
Related
MLB The Show 25 Cutting Its Worst Diamond Dynasty Feature Might Actually Make Me Play It
MLB The Show is making a significant change to how Diamond Dynasty works by cutting its worst feature, and it’s just what I needed to try the mode.
Manny Ramirez is best known for his time playing for the Boston Red Sox, but he was already an All-Star by the time he transferred from Cleveland in 2001. Known for his incredible batting power, he was closely associated with teammate David Ortiz for their combined offensive skills. With the Red Sox, Ramirez made it to the World Series Championship in 2004. He later played for the Dodgers, White Sox, and Rays before his retirement in 2011.
Debuting with the Red Sox in 1984, Roger Clemens is often acknowledged as one of the greatest pitchers in MLB history. With a long and storied career, Clemens played for the Blue Jays, the Yankees, and the Astros over 21 years. He’s the recipient of an American League Cy Young Award, AL MVP, and All-Star Game MVP, and holds the MLB record for most batters struck out in a single game with 20.
Related
I Can’t Wait To Try Out This New Feature In MLB The Show 25 – & It Could Change The Series Forever
MLB The Show 25’s recent trailer showed off some major gameplay innovations that could be the start of an exciting new direction for the series.
Although initially signed as a knuckleball pitcher, James “Cool Papa” Bell soon became better known for his speed and his ability to quickly run the bases. Bell was a two-time World Series champ and an eight-time All-Star, and also received a Ring of Honor from the Washington Nationals. He was inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1974, after also working as a scout for the St. Louis Browns.
All Returning Legends In MLB The Show 25
Who’s Coming Back For MLB The Show 25
MLB The Show 24 featured over 190 Legends, and the new roster crosses the 200 mark, with plenty of Legends from last year’s game returning. Again, these characters are all free at launch, although an internet connection is required to gain access to the roster. Legends are typically unlocked via MLB The Show‘s Diamond Dynasty mode, in which players collect the virtual baseball cards that allow them to add new players to their teams. The Legends trailer highlights some of the most iconic returning options:
- Satchel Paige
- Josh Gibson
- Babe Ruth
- Mark Davis
- Hank Aaron
- Derek Jeter
- Martín Dihigo
- Jackie Robinson
- Terry Pendleton
- Randy Johnson
- Mickey Mantle
The MLB The Show games tend to maintain the vast majority of the Legends catalog from each year to the next, so MLB The Show 24‘s roster can be expected to show up in relatively full force. The full array of 190 Legends in last year’s game is as follows:
- Roy Halladay
- Mike Mussina
- Randy Johnson
- Pedro Martinex
- Greg Maddux
- Tom Glavine
- Mariano Rivera
- Billy Wagner
- Brian Wilson
- Robb Nen
- Trevor Hoffman
- John Smoltz
- Derek Jeter
- Mark McGwire
- David Ortiz
- Larry Walker
- Ryan Braun
- Joe Mauer
- Chase Utley
- Ivan Rodriguez
- Frank Thomas
- Chipper Jones
- Vladimir Guerrero
- Sammy Sosa
- Ian Kinsler
- David Wright
- Alex Gordon
- Matt Holiday
- Tim Raines
- Mike Cameron
- Ryan Ludwick
- Rickey Henderson
- Tony Gwynn
- Ken Griffey Jr.
- Mike Schmidt
- Jim Thome
- Eddie Murray
- Mike Piazza
- Cal Ripken Jr.
- Joe Morgan
- Gary Carter
- Craig Biggio
- George Brett
- Andre Dawson
- Jeff Bagwell
- Orlando Cepeda
- Rod Carew
- Wade Boggs
- Paul Molitor
- Ozzie Smith
- Robin Yount
- Greg Vaughn
- Catfish Hunter
- Bret Saberhagen
- Don Sutton
- Tom Seaver
- Nolan Ryan
- Vida Blue
- Ron Guidry
- John Franco
- Tom Henke
- Bruce Sutter
- Rich Gossage
- Lee Smith
- J.R. Richard
- Fernando Valenzuela
- Jim Palmer
- Dennis Eckersley
- Jackie Robinson
- Mickey Mantle
- Willie Mays
- Hank Aaron
- Lou Gehrig
- Ernie Banks
- Ralph Kiner
- Eddie Matthews
- Johnny Bench
- Buck O’Neil
- Honus Wagner
- Duke Snider
- Roberto Clemente
- Joe Torre
- Harmon Killebrew
- Stan Musial
- Brooks Robinson
- Larry Doby
- Hank Thompson
- Martin Dihigo
- Rube Foster
- Phil Niekro
- Robin Roberts
- Hilton Smith
- Bob Feller
- Juan Marichal
- Whitey Ford
- Babe Ruth
- John Donaldson
- Fergie Jenkins
- Hal Newhouser
- Cy Young
- Satchel Paige
- Bob Gibson
- Warren Spahn
- Rollie Fingers
- Jim Edmonds
- Gary Sheffield
- Bert Blyleven
- Alan Trammell
- Eric Davis
- Todd Helton
- Edgar Martinez
- Willie McCovey
- Luis Gonzalez
- Willie Stargell
- Al Kaline
- Jason Giambi
- Grazy Sizemore
- Barry Larkin
- Tony Perez
- Troy Glaus
- Eric Gagne
- Carlos Delgado
- Don Mattingly
- Ryne Sandberg
- Dante Bichette
- Curtis Granderson
- Prince Fielder
- Ryan Howard
- David Justice
- Monte Irvin
- Jimmy Rollins
- Cliff Lee
- Minnie Minoso
- Billy Williams
- Jorge Posada
- Justin Morneau
- Paul Konerko
- Kevin Youkilis
- Rob Dibble
- Torii Hunter
- Steve Finley
- Johnny Damon
- Vinny Castilla
- Matt Cain
- Alfonso Soriano
- Roy Oswalt
- Kerry Wood
- A.J. Burnett
- Harold Baines
- Jason Bay
- Joe Nathan
- Michael Young
- Brandon Webb
- Brian Roberts
- Richie Ashburn
- Bill Mazeroski
- Jim Rice
- Lou Brock
- Dontrelle Willis
- Al Leiter
- Adam Dunn
- Mike Napoli
- Mark Prior
- Troy Percival
- Tim Salmon
- Luis Aparicio
- Tony Clark
- Mike Lowell
- Carlos Pena
- Ken Griffey Sr.
- Kyle Seager
- Chili Davis
- Jerry Hairston Jr.
- Raul Ibanez
- Andy Pettitte
- Johan Santana
- Andrew Miller
- Bernie Williams
- Adrian Baltre
- Richie Sexson
- Brian Dozier
- Rich Aurilia
- Tony Tarasco
- John Kruk
- Rafel Palmeiro
- Paul O’Neill
- Josh Gibson
- Buck Leonard
- Tony Stone
- Tony Oliva
This list is subject to change if MLB The Show 25 decides to omit certain Legends, but it should be largely representative of the overall returning cast. Remember, these Legends must be unlocked by playing through Diamond Dynasty mode; once the player discovers their cards, they can begin adding them to teams. As in previous years, Legends may also be available as free agents in MLB The Show 25‘s Franchise mode.
Will More Legends Be Confirmed For MLB The Show 25?
The Roster Looks Complete
It’s probably best to assume that MLB The Show 25 has now revealed its complete roster of Legends for the game’s launch, as it’s already announced more than the 16 that MLB The Show 24 revealed for launch. With over 20 new additions, there’s plenty of room to spare when hitting the promised 200+ mark, a likely indicator that a few old Legends will be on their way out.
That being said, more Legends could always come as updates in the future, so it’s worth staying tuned after the release of MLB The Show 25 to see how the game progresses. While the overall roster will ultimately be similar to last year, the addition of Ted Williams and some other greats is nothing to sneeze at. MLB The Show 25 is continuing to grow its impressive hall of fame, and even if no fan agrees with the exact lineup of players that have been designated as Legends, there’s certainly no shortage of talent to be found in the lineup.
Source: MLB/X
MLB The Show 25
- Released
-
March 18, 2025
- Developer(s)
-
San Diego Studio
- Publisher(s)
-
Sony Interactive Entertainment
